Short answer
Start by deciding how much income the portfolio has to replace each year, because that number, not the size of the check, sets how much risk you need to take. The main danger is expecting a diversified portfolio to earn what your business did; it will not, and reaching for that return is how newly liquid owners get hurt. Build a diversified, low-cost core sized to produce the income you need, and treat any rollover equity as a separate, speculative bet on top. Move in from cash in steps rather than all at once, holding Treasury bills or a money market fund first and investing to the plan over time. Put bonds and REITs in tax-deferred accounts, equities and municipal bonds in taxable accounts, and your highest-growth holdings in a Roth. In low-income years after the sale, rebalance in a tax-aware way. For many sellers a simple index portfolio plus a good CPA is enough.
Key facts
- The number that matters first
- How much income the portfolio must produce each year, not the size of the lump sum.
- The return trap
- A diversified portfolio is not built to earn the 20 or 30 percent an owner earned on their own company. Expecting it to leads to too much risk.
- Core plus rollover
- Build a diversified, low-cost core for the income you need. Treat rollover equity as separate speculation, not part of the core.
- Move in slowly
- Hold Treasury bills or a money market fund first, then invest to the plan in steps rather than all in one day.
- Asset location (2026 accounts)
- Bonds and REITs in tax-deferred, equities and municipal bonds in taxable, highest-growth in Roth.
Decide how much income the portfolio must replace, first
Before you pick a single investment, answer one question: how much money does this portfolio need to produce for you each year? That number, not the size of the check, decides almost everything that follows. Two owners can walk away with the same $6 million, and if one needs the portfolio to cover $250,000 of yearly spending while the other has a pension and only needs $60,000, they should not own the same portfolio. The first has to protect and produce income; the second can invest mostly for growth. Work out your real yearly spending, subtract any other income you will have, and the gap is what the portfolio must fill. Everything about your mix of stocks, bonds, and cash flows from that gap. The retirement math page walks through how to find the number.
Do not ask a portfolio to act like your business
As an owner you earned a high return on your own company. You knew it, you controlled it, and it rewarded the risk you took every day. It is natural to expect your money to keep earning like that. It will not. A diversified portfolio of public stocks and bonds is built to earn a much lower return than a good private business, and that is not a flaw; it is the price of being able to sell any day, spread your risk across thousands of companies, and stop working. The danger comes when a newly liquid owner, used to big returns, reaches for them in the portfolio. That reach usually means loading up on a few stocks, chasing a hot fund, or taking a large stake in something illiquid. When it goes wrong, you can no longer fix it by working harder, because the business that let you recover is gone. Plan around the steadier return a diversified portfolio can offer, and keep your appetite for a big win in one place: the rollover, which is already your speculative bet.
Build a boring core, keep speculation separate
The healthiest structure is simple. Build a diversified, low-cost core that is sized to produce the income you need, and keep anything speculative walled off from it and small. The core is broad stock and bond index funds, spread across many companies and held cheaply, plus enough safe assets to cover your near-term spending. It is meant to be dull and reliable.
Rollover equity, if your deal included it, is not part of the core. It is a single, illiquid, leveraged bet on one private company, and it belongs in its own mental bucket, planned as if it could be worth zero. If you want to own something adventurous with a slice of the liquid money, size it so that losing all of it would not change your life, and count it as separate from the money that has to produce your income. The rollover page covers how to live with the stake you already hold.
Move in from cash without buying everything in one day
You do not have to invest the whole check the week it lands, and you probably should not. Start with the money in safe, liquid holdings: Treasury bills, a money market fund, or a high-yield savings account. From there, move it into the plan in steps over a period of months rather than all at once. Investing a large sum in a single day exposes you to the bad luck of buying right before a drop, and just as important, it is hard to hold your nerve when a market you just entered falls. Spreading the purchases lowers both risks. Keep the money you will spend in the next few years in those safe assets the whole time, so an ugly market can never force you to sell investments at a loss to pay for groceries. A common approach is to hold a few years of spending in cash and short-term bonds and invest the rest to the plan.
Put each investment where it is taxed least
Two owners can hold the exact same investments and keep different amounts after tax, purely because of which account each investment sits in. This is asset location, and it is one of the few free improvements in investing. The rough rules:
- Bonds and REITs pay income taxed at ordinary rates, so they fit best in tax-deferred accounts like a traditional IRA or an old 401(k), where that income is not taxed each year.
- Stock index funds and municipal bonds belong in taxable accounts. Broad stock funds are tax-efficient on their own, and municipal bond interest is generally free from federal tax, so it does its job outside a sheltered account.
- Your highest-growth holdings are the best fit for a Roth, because everything a Roth earns comes out tax-free. Growth you never pay tax on is worth the most in the account that never taxes it.
You do not change your overall mix to do this; you just decide which sleeve holds which asset. Over years, the tax you save adds up without any extra risk.
Rebalance in a tax-aware way, especially in low-income years
Over time your mix drifts as some holdings grow faster than others, and bringing it back to plan is called rebalancing. Do it thoughtfully, because selling in a taxable account can create a tax bill. Two habits help. First, rebalance inside your tax-deferred and Roth accounts when you can, since trades there create no current tax. Second, when you do sell in a taxable account, lean on the quiet years right after the sale. Once your business income stops, you may fall into the lower long-term capital gains brackets, and in 2026 a married couple filing jointly pays zero on long-term gains up to $98,900 of taxable income and 15 percent up to $613,700. Selling appreciated holdings in a low-income year can cost far less than selling in your high-income sale year. You can also sell holdings that are down to bank losses that offset future gains. The year-after page shows how this fits with Roth conversions.
When a simple index approach is enough
Not every seller needs a complicated portfolio. If your exit was mostly cash, your spending is well below what a diversified portfolio can support, and your plan is to retire on that portfolio, a low-cost mix of broad stock and bond index funds, held in the right accounts and rebalanced now and then, does most of the work. Layers of funds, private deals, and complex products more often add cost and worry than results. Complexity starts to earn its place when there is a rollover to plan around, a concentrated stock position to unwind carefully, a large estate, or a multi-year tax picture from an earnout. Short of that, simple is the strong choice, not the lazy one. The advisor page is honest about which situation you are in.
When this does not apply to you
This page assumes you are investing a lump sum you can afford to leave largely invested. It does not fit if you need most of the money within a year or two, for a purchase or to pay a coming tax bill on an earnout or installment note, in which case safety and liquidity matter more than any investment plan. It also does not fit if your proceeds are small enough that the whole question is simply how to hold cash safely and retire, rather than how to build a portfolio. And if a large share of your net worth is still tied up in rollover equity, the more urgent work is planning around that concentration, not fine-tuning the liquid piece. None of these figures are a forecast of what any portfolio will earn.
What to do next
Write down your real yearly spending and subtract the income you will have from other sources; the gap is what the portfolio must produce. Keep the whole check in Treasury bills or a money market fund while you do this. Then build a diversified, low-cost core sized to that gap, decide which account holds each asset, and set a schedule to move in from cash over the next several months rather than all at once. Hold a few years of spending in safe assets so a bad market never forces your hand. Plan any rebalancing and Roth conversions for the low-income years ahead using the year-after page, and model the whole picture with the after-tax proceeds calculator. If you would rather have a second set of eyes before you invest, the contact page explains how a first conversation works, and who we serve describes the owners we are built for.
Questions people ask
How much of the proceeds should I invest in stocks?
It depends on how much income the portfolio has to produce and how steady you need that income to be, not on a fixed rule. An owner who needs the portfolio to replace most of their old income usually holds more bonds and cash for stability, while one who has other income and is investing mostly for growth can hold more stock. The honest starting point is your spending, then your other income, then the mix. See how much you need to retire.
Should I invest the whole check at once or spread it out?
Spreading it out over a period of months is the calmer choice for most sellers, because it lowers the chance of investing everything right before a drop and it matches the pace of building a real plan. Park the cash in Treasury bills or a money market fund first, then move it into the plan in steps. This is about behavior and peace of mind as much as math; a plan you can hold through a bad month is worth more than a perfect one you abandon.
Can my portfolio replace what my business earned?
Usually not, and expecting it to is the most common mistake. As an owner you earned a high return on a company you controlled and understood. A diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds is not built to do that, and reaching for those returns means taking risks that can hurt you when you can no longer replace the money by working. Plan around a diversified return, keep the rollover as your one speculative bet, and let the portfolio be boring on purpose.
What is asset location and why does it matter?
Asset location is deciding which kind of account holds each investment so you keep more after tax. As a rough guide, bonds and REITs, which throw off income taxed at ordinary rates, belong in tax-deferred accounts like an IRA. Stock index funds and municipal bonds fit taxable accounts, where they are more tax-efficient. Your highest-growth holdings are the best fit for a Roth, where the growth comes out tax-free. Getting this right can save real money over time without changing your overall mix.
Where should I keep the money I need in the next few years?
In safe, liquid holdings: Treasury bills, a money market fund, or short-term high-quality bonds. Money you will spend soon should not be exposed to the stock market, because a bad year could force you to sell at a loss to cover your spending. A common approach is to hold a few years of expenses in these safe assets so that a market drop never dictates your withdrawals.
Is a simple index portfolio really enough?
For many sellers, yes. A low-cost mix of broad stock and bond index funds, held in the right accounts and rebalanced now and then, does most of what a complex portfolio does at a fraction of the cost and worry. Complexity earns its place when there is a rollover to plan around, a concentrated position to unwind, a large estate, or a multi-year tax picture. If your situation is simpler than that, simple is not a compromise. See do I need an advisor.
Should I buy an annuity for guaranteed income?
Maybe, in part, but go in with clear eyes. Some retirees value having a floor of income they cannot outlive, and an income annuity can provide that. The trade-offs are real: your money is less liquid, the terms can be hard to compare, and the products are often sold with high commissions. If you consider one, use it for a portion of your spending, compare simple options, and be sure you understand what you give up. It is a tool for part of a plan, not the whole plan.
What should I do with a large cash position while I decide?
Hold it in Treasury bills, a money market fund, or a high-yield savings account, and spread balances so you stay within deposit and money-fund protections. Cash is a fine place to be for weeks or a few months while you build a plan. The risk of sitting in cash is not danger; it is drift, letting months turn into years so that inflation slowly erodes money that should be working toward your income. Set a date to have a plan and move.